Creators:
Screenstory: Ted Elliott
Terry Rossio
Stuart Beattie
Jay Wolpert
Screenplay: Ted Elliott
Terry Rossio
Actor: Johnny Depp
Analysis: Ms. Katherine Judd (Aka R.A. Brianna)
I've always loved complex characters and enjoy writing analysis of
them. But rarely do I find anger to be the motivation behind the
analysis. I have seen Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the
Black Pearl, sixty-four times in the theaters, and I've
read every review I could find, both on and offline. I must be the
only viewer in the world who saw more in Jack Sparrow than a comedic,
scene-stealing rogue-pirate. He is much more and does not deserve the
appellations of foolish, fey, foppish, inept, and sun-baked. If you
will, allow me to take you on a Jack
Sparrow character journey.
To do this analysis and provide
examples on each aspect of characterization, it would be best to start at
the beginning of the movie. The first sighting of Captain Jack Sparrow has
him standing at the location of what should be the crow's nest of a
sailing ship, rigged out in full pirate regalia, legs firm and steady on
the spar, gazing thoughtfully toward Port Royal. First appearance may
remind one of the Black Pirate or Mac the Knife; one is tempted to believe
firmly in this stern, black pirate as a man not to be crossed. He glances
down, grabs a rope lead, and drops to the deck…of a dinghy. Moreover, a
dinghy that is rapidly taking on water. Here is a pirate without crew or
friend. As he begins to bail water, he catches sight of three skeletal
remains of pirates hung from a crossbeam between two rocks at the entrance
to Port Royal Bay. Sweeping his hat off, he pays tribute to the fallen
fellow pirates. Not expected, as he should have acknowledged the dead with
either a stern look of hatred for the manner of death or simply ignored
them as the fortunes (or misfortunes) of piracy. This is not the
stereotypical pirate.
His “docking” is a grandstand display of supreme confidence in his
own ability to survive. As the dinghy nears the pier, it rapidly sinks,
leaving Jack to step smoothly from the crow's spar to the pier. With an
effete swagger, he begins walking along the pier as confidently as if he
just berthed the QE2. Halted by the pier patrol, he stops and minces his
way back. Told he must pay one shilling to tie up at the dock and give his
name, Sparrow glances back to his sunken dinghy with a look of
astonishment at being asked to pay; nevertheless, he pulls out three
shillings and requests the port official “forget the name.” Here one can
see the first aspect of Captain Jack Sparrow. Within one minute of
speaking to the port official, Jack correctly identifies him as a man who
can be easily bribed. As a pirate, Jack found his way into many ports and
learned to recognize “kindred spirits.” Once the bribe has been accepted,
Jack quickly walks away. He is not eager to draw attention to himself as a
dangerous pirate, hence the foppish walk, the winks, and the
generosity (though he does recoup his shillings by taking the port
official's purse. After all, the port official would have placed the extra
two shillings in his pocket, if not the entire three, so Jack apparently
feels they are square). As he strolls along the docks of Port Royal, he
keeps to the shadowy areas while he checks out the ships anchored in the
bay. A cautious look over his shoulder proves he has learned to watch his
own back, allowing one to believe that this instinct was born of long
practice. One can see his mind planning his next move---his new
transportation, the sleek, fast-moving Interceptor.
He heads down to the docks…and immediately spots two British
soldiers, lounging in the shade, whose duty it is to keep the docks clear
of civilians. Since they seem bound and determined to take him for a
civilian, Jack spouts a bit of fast-talking. Having heard the music coming
from the fort, he attempts to compliment them by asking how “two fine
upstanding gentlemen, such as yourselves, did not merit an invitation?” To
hide his interest in the Interceptor, Jack points out the
Dauntless, floating offshore as the more valuable ship. The officers
confirm Jack's suspicion that the Interceptor is faster than the
Dauntless, but Jack cannot resist teasing them by mentioning the
Black Pearl as being the fastest ship in the Caribbean. His intent was
to sidetrack the officials, and he succeeds, not due to his own sagacity
but to the Laurel/Hardy performance of the soldiers. His thoughts stand
written on his face. These people are morons! No wonder they are pulling
dock-duty. This will be too easy. As the soldiers argue, Jack quickly and
quietly slips onboard the Interceptor. When the soldiers realize
where Jack has gone and rush onboard, they find him calmly examining the
ship wheel and instruments. When the soldiers challenge Jack for his name,
he blithely gives the name of Smith, “or Smithy, if you like.” Asked for
his business and admonished to tell no lies, Jack decides to have fun with
them and tell the absolute truth, saying, “I confess. It is my intention
to commandeer one of these ships, pick up a crew out of Tortuga, and raid,
pillage, and plunder, and otherwise pilfer my weasley black guts out.” The
soldiers immediately start debating whether Jack is lying or telling the
truth. Jack honestly and rather forthrightly tells them that he knew “they
wouldn't believe the truth even if he told it to them,” another strong
indicator that Jack is smarter than he lets on, for, once again, he
pinpoints the mentality of these men and uses his quick wit to confuse and
befuddle them.
He proceeds to tell an outrageous story to the two men, which is
interrupted by the splash of Elizabeth's fall from the fort wall
overlooking the bay. After quickly ascertaining that neither of the
officers is capable of rescuing the girl and despite the fact that he
hoped to snag the Interceptor while they were occupied with said
rescue, Jack, while stripping off coat, hat, and weaponry, takes command,
insults the officers outright, then dives into the water. What pirate
would have bothered? Clearly, there is no profit in it for Jack. He has
lost his chance at the Interceptor, so why should he have worried
whether the girl lived or drowned? Jack reveals his sense of honor. He
cannot allow an innocent to suffer, regardless of the
disruption/interruption of his plans. He rescues Elizabeth with daring and
fortitude. He strips her dress from her to keep them both from drowning of
its weight, then, once safely on the dock, cuts off her corset so she can
begin breathing freely again. His reference to Singapore demonstrates,
rather roguishly, his acquaintance with feminine garments of that country
and displays his knowledge of other lands, opening to speculation what
other countries Jack has visited.
Up to this point, Jack only wants the Interceptor, but
Elizabeth wears a medallion that catches his eye. He asks in a tone of
wonder and determination, “Where did you get that?” He KNOWS what it is,
and it may lead him to the Black Pearl. His mind is in a whirl. He
knows he must discover this mystery, but the arrival of Commodore
Norrington, Governor Swann, and a host of armed soldiers throws the first
of several setbacks in Jack's plans to reacquire the Black Pearl.
Jack hesitates when Norrington offers to shake hands in gratitude for
his rescue of Elizabeth. In Norrington, Jack realizes that he just met a
man of some intelligence and is loath to reveal any information about
himself. But not to shake hands would prove that he had something to hide,
so he extends his hand. Norrington seizes the hand, examines Jack's arm,
and announces to all that this rescuer is none other than Jack Sparrow,
the pirate, to which Jack replies by requesting his full identity be told,
“Captain Jack Sparrow, if you please, sir.” Jack winces during the
examination of his personal effects, fearing his charade is over and
biting his tongue over the deprecations heaped on his reputation by
Norrington. His one good deed “seems enough to condemn him.” Yet he is
just waiting for the soldiers to move away from him. Jack throws his cuff
chain around Elizabeth's neck and demands his effects. Holding his pistol
to her head, he orders Elizabeth to attach his accoutrements. He clearly
enjoys having a beautiful woman in his arms, and he smirks at the agitated
Norrington. When all is in place, he tells Elizabeth, “I saved your life;
you saved mine. We're square.” He has no intention of harming her, merely
using her to affect some kind of escape.
Now he shows off his supreme confidence in himself as he announces,
“You'll remember this as the day you almost caught Captain Jack Sparrow!”
He must have escaped similar situations before to have this level of
arrogance and confidence, the latest being his escape from the East India
Company who branded him a pirate. Jack thinks quickly under stress as his
escape from the dock displays, though he's not above showing a bit of
honest fear at being fired upon while swinging around the loading boom. He
reverts to the bumbling persona when he hits the dock and starts running,
hoping still to convince people of his ineptitude.
He knows he must find a safe place and remove the iron cuffs, so he
ducks into a blacksmith's shop. Here he shows again the essential aspect
of his character…do not maim or kill unnecessarily. Examining the snoring
blacksmith and determining no threat, he proceeds with the business of
removing the irons. Hampered by the cuffs, which prevent him from
hammering them off, he quickly resorts to breaking them in the turning
cogwheel of the forge. His movements are quick and jerky, indicating his
agitation by the passage of time, knowing the soldiers are looking for
him.
Another setback occurs when Will Turner enters the shop. One can
almost hear Jack curse silently to himself. At first, he threatens Will in
a mild tone, convinced that Will must back away. Not so, as Will defies
Jack and grabs a sword. Not averse to fighting but focused on escape, Jack
maneuvers Will away from the door by patronizing Will's fighting
techniques. But Will proves a noble and surprising adversary, and Jack is
forced to fight. Realizing the clash of swords in the shop will bring the
soldiers running, Jack draws his pistol on Will. To Will's comment of “You
cheated,” Jack replies with the obvious answer, “Pirate,” indicating in a
single word the reputation of pirates to ignore rules and authority (as
well as to make Will look foolish, as in “Well, DUH!”) Jack has admiration
for Will's proficiency with a sword but thinks him too easily swayed to
conformity.
Still, Jack loathes killing without reason and tries to plead with
Will to “Please move!” Will stands firm, and the soldiers begin beating
down the door. Jack tries one last time to convince Will to move by
cocking his pistol and saying, “This shot is not meant for you.”
Unfortunately, Jack has forgotten the older blacksmith, who breaks an ale
bottle over Jack's head. As he falls, one can see the pain of the blow and
another silent curse.
Jack has been captured and put in prison to await his hanging at
dawn. Yet, to all appearances, Jack seems at ease and taking some much
needed rest in the cell. Other prisoners attempting to lure a dog, which
has the jail key in its mouth, to their cell seems only to annoy him
slightly while also providing amusement. When the sound of cannon fire
erupts, Jack is instantly alert. “I know those guns.” Confirming his
suspicions, Jack gazes intently down on the bay. “It's the Pearl.”
There is longing in his voice, as if he sees a long-lost lover. True to
his run of bad luck, the only cannon blast to hit the prison opens the
cell adjacent to Jack, allowing the other prisoners to escape and leaving
Jack to continue staring at the Black Pearl. Once alone, he grabs
an old bone and tries to lure the dog himself, but a sudden opening of the
prison door scares the dog, which runs away. Two pirates from the Pearl
enter and see Jack in the cell. Jack maintains his calm, though one can
see the anger in his eyes and stance, as the pirates taunt him with their
takeover of his ship. Jack makes several connections here: 1) Elizabeth's
medallion is part of a treasure Jack once sought to find. 2) The Black
Pearl attacks Port Royal the very night after Jack discovers the
medallion. 3) Therefore, the mates of the Black Pearl are after the
medallion and its owner.
Only one or two things remain to confirm Jack's suspicions. He taunts
the pirates in return, “Worry about your own fortunes, gentlemen. The
lowest portion of Hell is reserved for betrayers and mutineers.” This is a
clear indication of the dichotomy that is Jack Sparrow. During this time
period, Dante's Divine Comedy was being widely read throughout
Europe, and wealthy newcomers to America would have included this work in
their libraries. The appeal of the literary work lay in the fact that
Dante, for the first time, wrote a major work in the common tongue of
ordinary people, making it easily understood by the general populace. Has
Jack read Divine Comedy? There is no question that Jack Sparrow is
an educated man with a large vocabulary, much larger than the ordinary
pirate. That, plus his precise manner of speech, however slurred, confirms
Jack knows a great deal more than most people believe. One suspicion is
confirmed when one of the pirates grabs for Jack's throat. In the
moonlight, the pirate's arm is skeletal, causing Jack to expound, “So
there is a curse. That's interesting!” He has heard of the curse, but he
has not seen his mutinous crew in ten years. Now he makes the connection
between the Black Pearl's attack and Elizabeth's medallion.
Following this confirmation, one might assume he settled down for a nap in
his cell, knowing that “the key's run off” and he can do nothing else at
the moment. Yet, Jack spends at least part of the night filing down the
old bone into a pick.
The following morning, when no one arrives to take Jack to his
execution, he begins trying to pick the lock with the bone. He becomes
agitated again, “Come on! Please!” as he tenderly maneuvers the bone in
the lock. A loud noise makes him dive away from the door back into the
cell, reclining quickly on the floor and assuming a lazy appearance. Will
appears and demands information on the Black Pearl and its
location. Jack plays with him, telling some of the story but nothing
really pertinent. He, in true pirate fashion, tells Will there's no profit
for him to help Will. Will offers to free Jack from prison, which
intrigues Jack enough to ask for Will's name. Upon learning it, Jack makes
the connection very quickly, proving two things: 1) he knows that
Bootstrap Bill Turner had a son and 2) the son, Will, not Elizabeth, is
the key to regaining his ship. He agrees to lead Will to “the Black
Pearl and your bonny lass.” But he has no intention of revealing his
knowledge of the curse or his plans for Will.
Jack determines to commandeer the Interceptor, and he secures
Will's complete cooperation by goading him with “This girl…How far are you
willing to go to save her?” He takes Will on an underwater walk, using an
overturned canoe to provide an air pocket. Will pronounces this maneuver
either “brilliance or madness.” Jack's answer has a tone of world-weary
knowledge, “It's remarkable how often those two traits coincide.” Against
all odds (or perhaps because the British sailors do fear Jack a bit for
his eccentric behavior), Jack and Will climb aboard the Dauntless,
dispense with the crew, and together manage to get the ship moving toward
open water. One must assume Jack has told this portion of the plan to
Will, for it is Will who spies the Interceptor preparing to give
chase, Norrington at the helm. Jack allows the crew of the Interceptor
to tack alongside the Dauntless and come aboard, then he and Will
quickly swing over to the Interceptor, Jack cuts the boarding
lines, and they make sail for the open sea. Jack again cannot help
taunting Norrington with “Thank-you, Commodore, for getting us ready to
make way. We'd have had a hard time of it by ourselves!” This maneuver
inspires one official to proclaim Jack to be “the best pirate I've ever
seen,” a comment that Jack would have preened over, had he heard it.
Onboard the Interceptor, Will corners Jack into confessing to
knowing William Turner, to which Jack reveals not only that he “was one of
the few who knew him as William Turner,” but also Williams pirate name of
“Bootstrap or Bootstrap Bill.” Will challenges Jack over the knowledge
that William Turner was a pirate. If a bit roughly (catching Will off
guard and suspending him over the open sea with only the boom line to hang
on to), Jack tries to teach Will an important lesson, a lesson dealing
with choices. “The only rules that really matter are these: what a man can
do and what a man can't do. For instance, you can accept that your father
was a pirate and a good man, or you can't. But pirate is in your blood,
boy, and you'll have to square with that someday. Now me, for example, I
can let you drown. But I can't bring this ship into Tortuga all by me
onesies, savvy? So, can you sail under the command of a pirate or can you
not?” Jack has obviously had to make many such choices and knows the
importance of priorities. Choices or no, Jack waxes a bit philosophical
here…reminiscent of Singapore maybe?
On to Tortuga. Jack is familiar with and in Tortuga. If he does have
a home off-decks, perhaps it would be Tortuga. He rhapsodizes the filthy
and rambunctious port as a paradise saying, “It is indeed a sad lot that
has never breathed the sweet proliferous bouquet that is Tortuga!” One
notices tantalizing glimpses and innuendos of Jack's past. Two different
women slap Jack rather harshly, supposedly for past wrongs, long absences,
or broken promises. Jack appears the consummate rogue where the ladies are
concerned. Apparently, one encounter with Captain Jack Sparrow is more
than enough. Jack mourns or longs for no woman. Yet he loves Tortuga for
all it has to offer the freewheeling pirate. But…down to business.
Jack locates Mr. Gibbs, who lies sleeping in a pigpen. Gibbs,
awakened by a bucket of water flung by Jack, is obviously overjoyed to see
Jack again and is willing to listen to Jack's plans. Setting Will as
lookout (both to keep Will occupied and to keep him ignorant of Jack's
plans), Jack confides his knowledge and asks Gibbs to get a crew for the
Interceptor. Obviously, Jack and Gibbs are old friends, and Jack
trusts him to be loyal and true. (Maybe a bit off topic here, but one must
wonder why Jack knew he could find Joshamee Gibbs on Tortuga. Locating him
in the pigsty would be simply a matter of inquiry with the barkeep. Gibbs
was a sailor onboard the Dauntless eight years previously. Gibbs'
jubilance over Jack's reappearance could only mean the two have had no
contact in eight years. If Gibbs is truly the one person Jack now trusts
fully, one must also assume Jack kept tabs on his old friend.)
Gibbs finds a crew by morning, including another young woman with
whom Jack has a history. He stole Anamaria's boat, the Jolly Mon,
and, supposedly, this is the boat that sank its way into Port Royal's bay.
Jack's sense of honor rears its head again, though he skirts the issue of
theft via the use of semantics, telling Anamaria he “Borrowed…borrowed
without asking, but with every intention on bringing it back!” Jack wins
his ragtag crew by promising Anamaria the Interceptor will be hers.
Jack is in his element and has all he requires to begin his pursuit of the
Black Pearl. He sails through the night during a terrible storm,
exhibiting his knowledge of ships and seamanship. Gibbs seems somewhat
worried about their welfare when he tells Jack, “We should drop canvas,
sir!” But Jack replies, “She can hold a bit longer.” It seems that
nothing, not even nature's fury, can stop him from his plans to confront
and punish Barbossa and retake his ship.
Yet trouble follows Jack, as if it were a conscious entity seeking to
punish Jack for his arrogance and self-confidence. The Interceptor
arrives at Isla de la Muerta, and Jack takes Will with him to shore. Jack
proves himself to be thoroughly human by taunting Will about Will's
attitude about pirates—claiming that Will has almost acquired pirate
status himself, having “sprung a man out of jail, commandeered a ship of
the fleet, sailed with a buccaneer crew out of Tortuga, and you're
completely obsessed with treasure.” But Jack underestimates Will's youth,
determination, and brashness. He tells Will to wait for the opportune
moment, and, when challenged as to this moment, insults Will by telling
him to “stay here and try not to do anything stupid.” To which Will
answers with a blow to Jack's head with an oar, knocking Jack out.
Jack has lost control of the situation and must regroup quickly.
While no doubt sporting an enormous headache (which may be the reason his
listing walk seems more pronounced), Jack turns foppish and foolish; yet
he manages to stay his death long enough to invoke the right of parley.
When he doesn't see Will or Elizabeth, he wisely holds his knowledge of
Will Turner closely, merely telling Barbossa, “The girl's blood didn't
work, did it?” and “I know whose blood you need.” He proceeds to bargain
with Barbossa, exchanging the Black Pearl for the information
Barbossa requires. He is supremely confident that he has Barbossa over a
barrel—until the bo'son reports the Interceptor in sight. Yet
another setback! Jack may have assumed that Barbossa had the Aztec
medallion and needed only the correct blood to go with it. When he sees
the Interceptor, he realizes his mistake and attempts to regain his
advantage by requesting, “We run up a flag of truce, I scurry over to the
Interceptor, and negotiate the return of your medallion, eh. What
say you to that?” Barbossa still knows nothing of Will, and Jack wants to
keep it that way. But Barbossa turns the tables, stating “No. You see,
Jack, that's the very attitude that lost you the Pearl. People are
easy to search when they're dead!” and throws Jack into the brig.
By his manner of walk, one can see Jack is highly agitated but trying
to hold it in. He lives by fairness and honor, but true pirates have no
honor or regrets, hence Barbossa's willingness to kill to get what he
wants, while Jack will always try talk and rationale first before
violence. Once alone again in a cell, he immediately looks through a hole
in the shipside to watch what transpires. When the battle between the
Interceptor and the Black Pearl gets underway, Jack becomes
enraged, presumably at Will and Gibbs, for damage done to the Black
Pearl, shouting “Stop blowing holes in my ship!” But that one blast
opens the cell door, and Jack quickly ascends to the deck. He dislodges a
sailor from a rope and swings aboard the Interceptor. His mind is
on regaining the medallion, though he does prevent a pirate from shooting
Elizabeth and drops both of them out of gunfire. He quickly asks
Elizabeth, “Where's the medallion?” When Elizabeth draws back to strike
him, he sees the bandage on her hand, knows trial was made of her blood,
and realizes that Will probably has the medallion, so he questions, “Ah!
And where is dear William?” Elizabeth rushes off, but Jack remains,
watching everything closely, which is why he is the only one to see the
monkey with the medallion running across the fallen mast back to the
Black Pearl. Jack knows he must get that medallion to increase his
bargaining power with Barbossa. Despite a frantic chase, he loses and is
once again under Barbossa's control, as is Elizabeth and the
Interceptor's crew. As the Interceptor explodes, Jack winces,
thinking Will is dead and the curse will never be lifted. Yet,
miraculously, Will appears over the rail, seizes a pistol, and demands
Elizabeth's freedom. While, knowing Jack, he may have been planning his
next move, Will's appearance both elates and worries him---elates because
his plans may still succeed; worried because of Will's brashness and
inexperience with pirates. He pleads quietly, “Don't do anything stupid.”
Trying desperately to signal to Will not to reveal himself, Jack tries to
claim Will as an impotent lost relative but to no avail. Will tells
Barbossa who he is. Jack is frantic, trying to get Will to wise up and
name Jack as Captain of the Black Pearl. But Will is young and
totally misses the signals, though he does barter for the crew's safety
and Elizabeth's freedom. Barbossa agrees, then orders Elizabeth to walk
the plank. Jack is busily trying to makeup to his former crewmembers in
order to stay on the Pearl. Again, no avail. Barbossa forces Jack
to walk the plank as well, allowing him only his sword and his pistol with
one shot (which he must first rescue from the shoals before swimming to
shore).
Jack Sparrow is completely enraged and frustrated to be back at
square one, as demonstrated by his tone and expression in saying, “That's
the second time I've watched that man sail away in my ship.” This is the
same island he landed on ten years before, but now he feels his options
are limited. Elizabeth's demands for his past rescue forces him to answer
her roughly, “To what point and purpose, Missy? The Black Pearl is
gone. So, unless you have a rudder and lots of sail hidden in that bodice,
unlikely, young Mr. Turner will be dead long before you can reach him.”
Jack begins his new stay by searching out the old cache of rum, while
listening to Elizabeth's constant haranguing which angers him further. To
shut her up, he tells her truthfully he was on the island before only
three days before bartering passage off with the rumrunners.
Jack must be forgiven for getting drunk. He just wants his ship and
his freedom. He is tired, frustrated, and angry. While a seemingly drunk
Elizabeth is a minor distraction, Jack speaks longingly of what a ship is,
“not just a keel and a hull and a deck and sails—that's what a ship
needs—but what a ship is—what the Black Pearl really is—is
freedom.” This is the quintessential Captain Jack Sparrow: free-spirited,
freehearted, freedom-loving, and just plain free, period. Even though
drunk, he is already planning to get back to the Pearl, although just how
he does not as yet know. He gains a wild stroke of luck when he awakens
and sees Elizabeth's bonfire. While not at all happy that “the rum's
gone,” at least being rescued by the Dauntless puts him once more
into the game.
On board, he jumps to Elizabeth's aid in enlisting the Dauntless
to pursue Will and, by extension, Barbossa. He sways Norrington by saying,
“The Pearl was running near the scuppers after the battle. It's highly
unlikely she'd be able to make good time. Think about it! The Black
Pearl! The last real pirate threat in the Caribbean, mate. How can you
pass that up?” After Elizabeth promises to wed Norrington in exchange for
rescuing Will, Jack erupts with elation, knowing his plans are back in
line, “Weddings! I love weddings! Drinks all round!” Contritely, he offers
his hands for the chains—a beguilement to diffuse Norrington. Jack gives
the bearings of Isla de la Muerta and comports himself well on the
journey. So well, in fact, that Norrington takes him along to set up the
attack on the pirates.
As he rows once more into the cave, Jack's expression of pure
contentment and mischief relays his joy at once more confronting Barbossa
and regaining the Pearl. Stopping the blood ritual by informing
Barbossa of the lurking Dauntless, Jack maneuvers himself close to
the treasure he sought ten years earlier. He manipulates Barbossa onto
postponing the ritual until the Dauntless has been captured. He
even offers to sail under Barbossa, an offer Jack has no intention of
keeping. But Jack must still deal with Will, who he hopes has finally
learned some discretion. To Barbossa's question of killing Will, Jack
replies, “By all means, kill the whelp. Just not yet. Wait to lift the
curse… and he looks hard at Will as if to say 'pay close attention here
and don't screw this up again,' …until the opportune moment. For instance,
after you've killed Norrington's men. Every last one.” Playing with the
gold medallions, Jack slyly slips one into his glove. It's a gamble. Jack
knows he's cursed now but wants the protection of the curse in his
confrontation with Barbossa.
As Jack had hoped, most of the pirates leave for their takeover of
the Dauntless, leaving only Barbossa, Jack, Will, and three pirates
as guards in the cave. Jack wants to fight Barbossa, not the other three.
He begins bantering with Barbossa, telling him “I'm dishonest. You can
always trust a dishonest man to be dishonest. Honestly. It's the honest
ones you have to watch out for, because you can never predict when they're
going to do something incredibly stupid.” With that, Jack seizes a
pirate's sword, throws it to Will, draws his own sword, and goes after
Barbossa. Does this make Jack an honest man or merely manipulative? One
inclines to the latter, as it is in keeping with Jack's plan and
character. The fight ensues, and the curse does keep Jack from dying. When
Elizabeth arrives and helps Will dispose of the guards, Jack slaps his
stolen medallion into his hand, slices the hand with his sword, grips
tightly, and tosses the medallion to Will. Barbossa takes aim on
Elizabeth, and Jack shoots Barbossa. Will's and Jack's coins fall into the
chest, releasing Jack and Barbossa from the curse. Barbossa dies from the
gunshot wound.
Jack promptly starts scrounging for treasure and loading himself down
with it. And who can blame him? He's waited for ten years for this moment.
He does have some sympathy for Will's inability to express his love for
Elizabeth, telling him, “If you were waiting for the opportune moment…that
was it,” but his mind is solely on taking back the Black Pearl….his
ship and his freedom, saying, “Now, if you don't mind, I'd be much obliged
if you'd drop me off my ship.” Elizabeth deflates this elation by telling
him the Interceptor crew sailed away from danger with the Black
Pearl. Devastated, Jack still does not blame the crew, as “They done
what's right by them. Can't expect more than that.” His dream is over. His
ship is gone once again. He will face a hanging in Port Royal for piracy.
And he is resigned to it.
In Port Royal, Jack stands quietly, listening to his “list of
crimes,” smiling wryly as he remembers some of his past escapades. A hint
of his arrogance remains as he corrects the herald “Captain! Captain Jack
Sparrow!” wishing that, just once, those strait-laced Englishmen would get
it right. He calmly puts his neck in the noose, prepared to die. Will
Turner comes to his aid, throwing a sword under the platform upon which
Jack lands. Surprised, Jack grasps at one last chance to escape. In the
ensuing battle, the hangman cuts the rope around Jack's neck, and he falls
to the ground. Leaping up, Jack quickly cuts the bounds from his hands on
the impaled sword, joins Will, and they battle together, trying
desperately to get clear of the soldiers. But no…too many. Surrounded,
Jack stands behind Will, waiting to see if another opportunity will
present itself. And it does, though not as Jack expected. Both Will and
Elizabeth stand up for Jack, proclaiming him “a good man.” Jack accepts
this act of friendship as his due. Glancing up, he spies Cotton's parrot
flying out over the bay. He knows the Black Pearl is near!
As Jack realizes he will be allowed to go free, he becomes once again
the happy-go-lucky Captain Jack Sparrow and has parting words for
everyone. After bidding all a sarcastic farewell, Jack jumps to the
parapet and starts to make his usual “This is the day you'll always
remember…” speech, but he stumbles backward over the parapet and falls
into the bay. Accident…or careful planning? He spent the time behind Will
glancing around at the escape routes. Upon surfacing, he sees the Black
Pearl sailing toward him, resplendently clean and sporting brand new
sails. As he nears the ship, he grabs a rope thrown by Cotton and is
hauled onboard. Once there, he sternly asks Gibbs, “I thought you were to
hold to the code.” But Jack knows he's home. One last surprise comes from
Anamaria, to whom Jack owes a ship. Holding his coat, she says, “Captain
Sparrow, the Black Pearl is yours,” revealing in this one statement
the crew's loyalty and willingness to sail under Captain Jack Sparrow, no
matter how odd he may appear to be. Jack lovingly approaches the wheel,
caressing it with a look of pure joy until he realizes the crew is
watching. He barks out his orders, “On deck, you scabrous dogs! Hands to
braces. Make our hull ready to run free!” No more mincing or slurred
words…Captain Jack Sparrow is in command! As the crew scrambles to duty,
Jack turns his face forward to the sea, murmuring, “Now, bring me that
horizon!” As they set sail, he cannot resist a roguish “Drink up, me
hearties! YO HO!” Captain Jack Sparrow is free at last!
This rather lengthy walk through Pirates of the Caribbean: The
Curse of the Black Pearl illustrates several key facets of Captain
Jack Sparrow.
Manner: The foppish, fey, and wincing Jack Sparrow is not the
real Jack Sparrow. Jack Sparrow is too sure-footed on deck and on land.
His fighting skills reveal strength and agility born of practice and
application. After all, Jack fought for ten long years to regain the
Black Pearl. He lost his innocence and naiveté, and he learned a great
deal about human nature. He knows the drunkard and the simpleton will
always pass through crowds with little or no notice. The pirate brand
makes this disguise all the more necessary, therefore one suspects the
disguise as an elaborate scheme designed specifically for the goal of
regaining the Black Pearl. True, he's a drinker, carouser, and
rogue, but he is also dedicated to his own goals and a life of freedom on
the high seas. No action is too foolish if it assists in the attainment of
that goal. While Jack does, indeed, seem to switch sides frequently, he
never fails to remain on target and in pursuit of his main goal. Nor does
he ever compromise on his principles. The only person who suffers harm at
Jack's hand is the one person Jack swore to harm…Captain Barbossa, his
“murderous first mate!” He even leads Barbossa to believe him mad and
ineffectual, until the moment Barbossa looks down the barrel of Jack's
pistol and sees a look of a hunter who has won his prey!
Education: This aspect is more deduction than immediate
notice. But thanks to a look into the early version of Jack Sparrow
provided by Stuart Beattie and Jay Wolpert, this author learned that Jack
worked as a cartographer in England and managed to commission the Black
Pearl on his own. Cartography was not an easy job; it required an
education to start with and intensive training in map-making, therefore
Jack must have had a good education as a child. In England of the time
period, only wealthy people could afford to educate their children, so
Jack may have been a second or third son of a wealthy person, though
probably not royalty. He would have learned reading, writing, mathematics,
and literature, which could explain his reference to Dante's Divine
Comedy. He would also have learned to use the sword as part of his
early training. Jack Sparrow is an educated man. His manner of speech,
even when slurred, is precise, marking him as one of the wealthier classes
and explaining his ease with higher society. How and why he chose to
become a pirate is a matter of speculation. He loves his freedom, but, as
a younger son of a wealthy family, he may have been told he must do what
was right for his family, which would entail remaining in England and
under his father's thumb. Certainly, he is self-educated in the ways of
piracy. He is also a bit of a philosopher, probably acquired both from ten
years of foot-loose (or ship-loose) roaming and his earlier classical
education. He has visited several countries and experienced several
different cultures. He has met good men and bad, simpletons and noblemen,
whores and ladies…every aspect of society lies in his experience. He
slides too easily from one class to another for it to be only a hoax he
thought of on the spur of the moment. Jack plans every detail of his
ventures and uses all the weapons of his physical, mental, spiritual, and
emotional arsenal. He is a master manipulator but with a sure sense of
justice and a code of ethics by which he lives his life. He lectures Will
about facing and dealing with his (Will's) heritage. He understands
honesty and dishonesty, honor and dishonor. In fact, one could make a case
that Jack was referring to himself and his ten-year wandering when he
tells Will “it's remarkable how often those two traits (brilliance and
madness) coincide.” This author is strongly reminded of Odysseus and his
ten-year wandering to return home to Ithaca, equating Jack with Odysseus
and the Black Pearl with Penelope/Ithaca. Who will write the tale
of Captain Jack Sparrow's odyssey?
Appearance: On the surface a fey, sun-baked, rum-soaked rogue
who lives each moment to its fullest, Jack is, instead, a fast yet
thorough thinker. His plans are already in motion when he sails into Port
Royal. His physical appearance is just as a pirate would be, especially
one who has been wandering in search of his ship for ten years. The beads
and bangles may have been an addition to enhance the idea of insanity.
With each setback, he finds a way to get back on track. Deductively, he
would have found his way without the aid of Will Turner and Elizabeth
Swann…it may have taken a bit longer, but he would have found a way. He is
single-minded and extremely focused. Friends he has, if few, Mr. Gibbs
being one. And he wins admiration despite his apparent lack of concern for
the people he uses.
Personality/Character: Jack is a good man. One cannot know if
he began his pirate life that way, but, after ten years, he has learned
valuable lessons. He will not kill or maim unless absolutely necessary. He
goes out of his way to save Elizabeth from drowning, to educate Will, and
to assist the British soldiers in their fight against the cursed pirates.
He never harms Elizabeth or Mr. Brown, the blacksmith. He does not hit
women, though provoked enough to do so (Elizabeth's rant and bonfire on
the deserted island). He does live by a code, a code that has been
modified over ten years. He simply wishes to be what he is, a pirate
captain at the helm of his own ship. He is happiest when seeking “that
horizon.” By himself, he will harm no man, woman, or child. But provoke
him or do wrong by him, watch out! Jack Sparrow has a long memory and a
keen mind for plans and details.
He may seem foppish, fey, foolish, and inept, but Captain Jack
Sparrow is a deeply complex man who loves his precious freedom. Not much
gets by him. He is ever watchful and observant, both of his environment
and human nature. One must wonder if rum is not the only thing he “drinks
up, me hearties. Yo Ho!”
Works Cited
All dialogue courtesy of:
Elliott, Ted and Terry Rossio. Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse
of the Black Pearl.
Producer: Jerry Bruckheimer. Director: Gore Verbinsky. Buena Vista
Motion Pictures Group.
Walt Disney Pictures. July 9, 2003.
R.A. Brianna, also known as Katherine Judd, is our resident Pirate
of Many Talents, among them teaching writing composition to college
students. We're glad she shared her Captain Jack character analysis with
us!